By Ann Martin, Earth Island Journal
Posted on June 15, 2007, Printed on June 18, 2007
The commercial pet foods industry rakes in billions of dollars annually. In exchange for our dollars, we trust the companies to provide our pets with quality nutrition. The recent pet food recall demonstrated that our trust has been misplaced. But while many were shocked by the tragic deaths of beloved pets, many more would be shocked to know that the pet food industry has a long history of mistreating our pets. I first began researching the industry in 1990, when my two dogs became ill after eating a well-known commercial food.
The first thing that came to light was the fact that the pet food industry is virtually self-regulated. The only requirement that the industry must meet is to adhere to the Labeling Act, which states that food must contain the name and address of the producing company, whether the product is intended for dogs or cats, the weight of the food, and the guaranteed analysis. The source of the protein included in the analysis can be anything: condemned material from slaughterhouses, road-kill, zoo animals and even euthanized companion animals. Of course, the industry denies all this, especially the use of dead dogs and cats in pet foods. However, a senior official from a large rendering conglomerate in the United States wrote to me, “I know of no rendering company in the U.S. that will segregate companion animals from the rest of the raw material they process.”
Dog eat dog?
I personally have been able to trace euthanized pets from veterinary clinics in the city where I live to rendering plants where they are processed; the end results are shipped to pet food companies. Pentobarbital, the drug used to euthanize these animals, ends up being fed to our pets. Results of a study conducted by the University of Minnesota show that pentobarbital “survived rendering without undergoing degradation.” In the late 1990s, officials from the Food and Drug Administration, Center for Veterinary Medicine (FDA/CVM) decided to investigate a theory that dogs were exposed to pentobarbital through dog food. Researchers developed a test to detect pentobarbital in dry commercial dog foods.
Tests were conducted in 1998 and again in 2000. The first series of tests detected only the presence of pentobarbital but did not indicate the levels that were present in the foods. The second series of tests used 25 samples: 15 were found to contain pentobarbital. Ol’ Roy, Heinz, Kibbles ‘n Bits, Trailblazer, Dad’s, Purina Pro Plan, Reward and a number of lesser-known brands were among the pet foods showing various levels of pentobarbital. In tests designed to dispute that dogs and cats are the source of pentobarbital in pet food, the FDA/CVM conducted DNA testing to ascertain what animals might be in the food. In a statement released on its Web site, it said that no dog or cat DNA was found and that “the pentobarbital residues are entering pet food from euthanized, rendered cattle and even horses.”
Their report two years later in the American Journal of Veterinary research contradicted these findings. “None of the 31 dog food samples examined in our study tested positive for equine-derived proteins.” Additionally, they stated: “Cattle are only occasionally euthanized with pentobarbital, and thus are not considered a likely source of pentobarbital in dog food.” Their conclusion? “Although the results of our study narrow the search for the source of pentobarbital, it does not define the source (i.e., species) responsible for the contamination.
Hold the poison, please
According to the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FFDCA), pet food is considered adulterated if the “food is packaged or held under unsanitary conditions, food or ingredients are filthy or decomposed, and foods contain any poisonous or deleterious substance.” As pentobarbital is considered a poisonous drug, it would therefore be logical that the FFDCA would work to remove that substance from pet foods.
I asked Dr. Stephen Sundlof, director of the FDA/CVM, what steps the organization would undertake to remove pentobarbital from all commercial foods. His reply: “This drug is not approved for use in pet food, so it should not be present in these foods. That being said, CVM is not planning to undertake any special enforcement efforts to detect pentobarbital in pet foods.”
The contention of the FDA/CVM is that this drug was found in such small amounts in the pet foods that it should not cause a problem. Dr. Tamara Hebbler of the Healing Hope Animal Clinic in San Diego, Calif., disagrees. By feeding your pets foods that contain even traces of pentobarbital, Hebbler states, “you can definitely be slowly causing chronic degenerative disease to happen, much, much faster.”
Along with a euthanizing drug that could be in your pet food, you’ll find additives, preservatives, vitamins, and mineral mixes that are usually added in higher amounts than deemed necessary because the processing can degrade these supplements. At present dog food manufacturer Royal Canin is facing a $50 million class-action suit on behalf of pet owners who claim that some of Royal Canin’s foods contain excess levels of vitamin D, often damaging or fatal to pets.
Over the years, there have been numerous pet deaths caused by foods contaminated with mycotoxins, caused by a fungus found in moldy grains. One of the mycotoxins — vomitoxin — can cause diarrhea and vomiting in pets but is seldom fatal. This toxin was the cause of the Nature’s Recipe recall in 1995. In December of 2005, aflatoxin, a deadly form of mycotoxin, was found in food produced by Diamond Pet Foods. The company recalled 34 million pounds of contaminated dog and cat food that eventually killed over 100 dogs. According to the American Veterinary Medical Association, Diamond failed to follow company guidelines for aflatoxin testing and shipped contaminated products.
In a warning letter from the FDA, Diamond was advised that testing of retained samples “revealed aflatoxin levels between 90 and 1,851 parts per billion (ppb).” Acceptable levels are less than 20 ppb. People lost their beloved pets because a company chose to take the easy route and not bother with proper testing.
March 2007 saw the largest recall in the history of the industry. Menu Foods, a Canadian-based company, recalled more than 60 million cans and pouches of wet food that had been distributed all over North America. Iams, Eukanuba and Nutro were implicated in the scandal. Eventually Nestle Purina, Royal Canin, Diamond Pet Foods and Hills Pet Nutrition were added to the list, and in early April, some dry foods and pet treats were also included in the recall.
Sunshine Mills and Del Monte recalled dog biscuits and other pet treats. In total, over 153 brands of pet foods and treats were taken off the shelves. Natural Balance, which many considered safe and top of the line, also recalled a line of its foods. The cause? Wheat gluten and rice protein concentrate contaminated with melamine, a material used to manufacture kitchen utensils, and, in China, fertilizer.
Melamine was added to the wheat and rice to boost the protein levels. Two U.S. companies had imported the contaminated wheat and rice from China, and it was distributed to a number of pet food operations across North America. The number of reported deaths and illnesses in pets varied, depending on the source, from 16 to more than 3,000.
Later in the investigation, a team at the University of Guelph also found cyanuric acid and melamine in the tissues, kidneys and urine of infected pets. (Cyaniric is a stabilizer used in swimming pools.) “We took some ordinary cat urine and added three drops of melamine and three drops of cyanuric acid, and we got the identical crystals that we see in the kidneys of the affected cats,” said team leader Brent Hoff, a clinical toxicologist and pathologist.
It was also learned that American Nutrition of Ogden, Utah, a company that processed a number of foods for various companies, had added the contaminated rice protein to these products unbeknownst to the companies involved.
I have talked to many people who are skeptical that the pet food industry would use such inferior ingredients. But slowly they are beginning to question what they are feeding their pets. We have seen the rates of cancer, liver and kidney disease; autoimmune diseases; allergies; and skin problems rise in the years since this industry grew.
As our veterinary bills mount, we have been brainwashed by the industry to think that if we feed our pets human food, we will be causing them great harm. While it is not recommended to include your pets in your junk food habits, there is no harm in sharing a well-balanced diet with your pet. You wouldn’t want to eat food from the same bag every day, so don’t force your pets to do just that.
Ann Martin is the author of Food Pets Die For (NewSage Press, 2003) and Protect Your Pet (NewSagePress, 2001). The updated version of Food Pets Die For will be available in November 2007.
© 2007 Independent Media Institute. All rights reserved.
View this story online at: http://www.alternet.org/story/54236/
It sums up the blog, but just who be the clannies, really?
Tipped Ear Clan - Singapore Cats: the Homeless, the Homeseeking, and the Homeslackers of the 2 kitty mojo robbing siblings who serve the CLAN.
Looking for caregivers in these areas. Somebody wants to talk to you!
(Posted 28 Feb 08)
Olympics clean-up Chinese style: Beijing 2008 propagate death camp for cats and dogs
TEC’s Kitties Looking For Homes
Foster Mum’s Critters Looking For Homes
(Please send enquiries to sephycat at gmail dot com)
HOMESEEKING AND KITTY TLC
* What breed/pattern/colour is Kitty?
* Kitty TLC and preptime primer aka launching pad for finding out cat tlc stuff tec has gathered.
- NOTE especially Hey, what's that in my food dish??
* Smokers: Think of your pet before lighting your next cig
* Happy cats DON'T need balls
* Keep yourself up-to-date on some of the ongoing kitty supplies promos: Cat Supplies Bulletin
* Read about the pet food recall and other pet food related issues via our pet food recall tag and our *** PET FOOD RECALL *** page.
TNRM AKA MOJO ROBBERY
* TNRM - minions on cat business
* No-Kill Communities and the importance of TNRM
* Speak up against this ridiculous rule - HDB pet rule specifically BANS cats only
* "Good karma feeding" kill cats
SOS – YOUR HELP NEEDED, PLEASE
SOS - Singapore
URGENT APPEAL: Allow all breeds of Dogs and Cats in HDB flats. (Ref: Petition: Allow all breeds of Dogs and Cats in HDB flats)
SOS - Asia
* HELP: Stop the cruel Korean dog and cat meat market
* Help Stop the cruel Chinese/Guangdong dog and cat meat market
SOS - World
* The White Tiger Fraud or Meet the real captive-bred white tiger
(Wah, the vaulted Singapore Zoological Gardens also got White Tigers leh!)
* China's Shocking DOG and CAT fur trade.
* 'Pet' Foods and Animal Testing Policies. And do you know what's in the food you feed your kitties?
* Circuses.com: Please say "No", because animals can't.
* Tyke the elephant, and her fellow victims of Captive Animal Entertainment.
- Area1: Schwinger Central
- Area1: Snippety Happy
- New kitty in the hood
- Sophie has found her home
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Vicky
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Sophie
- Pierre may lose his eye…
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Cherrie
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Bee Hoon
- Homeseeker: Josh
- Appeal: Homes needed for loving angel towing 8 little devils
- Appeal for Homeless Pierre: going blind and needing a home
- Help: Save the pigeons living in Singapore
- We’re back!
- Get your CNY goodies fix and do a good turn at the same time!
Readers’ Choice Kibble
- BEWARE Hartz tick and flea control products
- My cat is a what-what-what?
- Getting a urine sample from kitty
- Hey, what’s that in my food dish??
- Why Do East Asians Eat Dog/Cat meat?
- Letter writing example
- Meet the real captive-bred white tiger
- Cat litter - An experiment in silicon gel
- In Singapore, authorities exercise classism towards volunteers
CURIOUS CATS FOLLOWED TEC PAWPRINTS TO THESE PLACES
- Adoption Ins and Outs
- Eh wait, since these are stray cats, do I have to pay to adopt? (3)
- Adoption – Cat Lost and Found. A Year-Long episode of anxiety and worry (1)
- Adoption Agencies (5)
- Guardians we be (4)
- I ABSOLUTELY can’t have a 2nd cat – my psychokitty will have a hissy-fit! (1)
- More on why fosters can’t help but seem like drill sergeants (1)
- Sealed with a kiss. Actually, tons of faith. (2)
- So what’s your trip about this adoption thing? (1)
- The cat isn’t behaving like you described, what gives? (1)
- The Good, The Bad & The Ugly (4)
- Foster Mum’s Homeseekers
- If You Take the Time To Understand Them, Cats Make Great Pets
- Questions the potential cat parent must consider
- Starter Kit and FAQ for the Kitty Foster/Rehomer
- Adoption Ins and Outs
- Tipped Ears
- Abandonment and homelessness
- Club Rad – irrational cat complainants
- Feeding the army – essentials
- Filing a police report in cases of ABUSE
- Government (ir)rationale for banning cats from 85% of homes
- How to sterilise stray cats?
- Ok, I get TNRM now. Cool! Where do I sign up?
- Responsible Feeder Bag
- Singapore’s Love-Hate Relationship with TNRM
- The Clannies dictating our lives
- TNRM – minions on cat business
- TNRM 101 – the Practical Handbook you can’t buy, but can read for FREE
- TNRM Useful Resources
- Tracking – TNRM Reimbursement from CWS
- What’s TNRM?
- Why the reluctance to sterilise
- You Don’t Have To LOVE Them, Honest!
- A little primer on those health test results
- Acute/Chronic Renal Failure (CRF) – aka Kidney problems
- Bad Habits – Destructive Chewing
- Brain Damage – A plausible vaccination after-effect
- Cat litter – An experiment in silicon gel
- Cat Litter – Is Pine A Good Alternative?
- Cat Litter – So what’s out there
- Cat litter – the bin
- Cat Litter – To Scoop or Not to Scoop
- Cats no-no for asthma kids? Hogwash
- Collar – hot and bothersome
- Dental care – Mum, Dad, my mouth hurts
- Does Kitty ass-drag across the sofa, or just smell bad ‘there’?
- Don’t give old Jolly Rogers a chance to laugh at your pet’s expense
- Enrichment – Scratch Post
- Enrichment – toys
- Essential kitty care references for the cat parent
- Feline Immunodeficiency Virus (FIV)
- Feline Infectious Enteritis (FIE)/feline parvovirus (FPV)/feline panleucopenia
- Feline Infectious Peritonitis (FiP)
- Feline Leukemia (FeLV)
- Feline Lymphoma/Cancer/Tumours
- Fireworks – it’s no party for pets!
- Genetic defects & white cats with different coloured eyes
- Getting a urine sample from kitty
- Handy contacts for the Singapore animal guardian
- Hey, are you changing my food?
- Hey, are you making my dinner?
- Hey, can we have a water refill here
- Hey, is my kibble fresh?
- Hey, is that tuna good for me?
- Hey, is your kitty’s food warm and toasty when delivered?
- Hey, what’s that in my food dish??
- Introducing a new kit into the bloc: How To Avoid the “Wham! Bam! Hissy-Fits” Syndrome
- Kitty Allergies – Food
- Making Kitty eat his meds
- Micro-chipping: Cat NRIC
- Mum, Dad, why am I itching?
- Never crash diet the moggie either
- On the other hand, you don’t want to be the lord-parent of the species either
- One is really not the answer you want
- PETFOOD RECALL
- Quick, call the vet!
- Roly poly isn’t cute, unless you’re a whale stocking up for summer
- Safety: Keep kitty indoors!
- Safety: Mesh up your windows
- Scratching Below the Surface- Cat Scratching as Communication
- Scratching: A Cat’s Prerogative
- Smokers: Think of your pet before lighting your next cig
- Sun-burning cats and lumpy skin
- Travelling… in terror?
- Vaccination and cancer
- Vegan diet for cats? Still a controversy
- Abandoned Pets (89)
- Abuse and Cruelty (202)
- Advocacy (284)
- Animal helpers online (81)
- Animals (906)
- Animals with disabilities (26)
- Bird Flu (8)
- Blogging Animals (4)
- Blogging Cats (129)
- Blogging Matters (16)
- Caterati (39)
- Cats Online (30)
- CATssociates (5)
- Community Spirit (47)
- Complaints (36)
- Foster Mum (173)
- Ah Yoke (1)
- Andie (1)
- Apple Pie (2)
- April (1)
- Blackie-Insecticide Spray Victim (3)
- Blessing (1)
- Bonnie aka Yo Yo (2)
- Boston (2)
- Cadbury (2)
- Debbie aka Gabbie (5)
- Diamond (1)
- Gemma (1)
- Happy the dog (1)
- Karma (3)
- Kitty Boy (3)
- Kobe aka Dungye (2)
- Little Star (1)
- Mas 3 legs (1)
- Perth (2)
- Porkribs (3)
- Santhi (6)
- Shadow (4)
- Snowy (1)
- Sunshine the dog (1)
- Sweety (3)
- Timmy the dog (5)
- Twinkle (5)
- Vira (1)
- Foster Mum – tec clannies in her care (117)
- Foster Mum's homeseekers (57)
- Foster Mum's homeseekers-no longer home seeking (40)
- Home Slackers (98)
- Homeseekers / Adoption (256)
- Homeseeking no more (246)
- Aaren (6)
- Aidan (1)
- Alvi (1)
- April Girl (17)
- Ariel (1)
- Asher (2)
- Austen (6)
- Bobby (2)
- Booties (24)
- Cassie (47)
- Dharma and Sanga (16)
- Freda (9)
- Freddy (10)
- Gunnar and Mattie (10)
- Izzy (32)
- Joe Yeti (14)
- Lavi (1)
- Lizzy (6)
- Lucas (39)
- Mandy (2)
- Mio (5)
- Neo (8)
- Orli (6)
- Remy (4)
- Sachiko (2)
- Sakiko (2)
- Sara (12)
- Timmi (26)
- Humour (74)
- Irresponsible Feeding (15)
- Kitty TLC (225)
- Letters & Rants (65)
- Missing in action (7)
- Mojo Robbery Care Package / TNRM (235)
- Monthly stats (21)
- News (186)
- Over the rainbow bridge (14)
- Pet food recall (17)
- photography (5)
- Quotes (3)
- Rambling / Minion wunderings (191)
- Random (140)
- Reviews / recommendations (13)
- SARS (4)
- Social Commentary (132)
- The Clans (331)
- Area 1 (137)
- Area 2 (125)
- Abby (1)
- Bambi (9)
- Bella (6)
- Benji (18)
- Benny (3)
- Berry (1)
- Bradley (9)
- Branden (1)
- Brayden (2)
- Brenna (3)
- Brennan (2)
- Brielle (5)
- Brina (2)
- Brina'sUnnamedAgoutiKitten (2)
- Buddy (16)
- Buffy (3)
- DiluteCalicoMale (2)
- Jet (3)
- Kenji (9)
- Omi (11)
- Pierre (3)
- Robby (1)
- Saba (12)
- Sabia (2)
- Sadi (2)
- Sally (9)
- Sarsi (3)
- Sasha (18)
- Satin (4)
- Scottie (8)
- SpottedTabbyMale2008 (1)
- Stanley (13)
- Sumie (5)
- Sunny (5)
- TabbyGirl20090401 (1)
- TabbyWhiteKitten200803 (2)
- Twinkie (2)
- WhiteCat-Saba'sHouseMate (1)
- WhiteKittenCalicoPatch2008 (1)
- Area 3 (63)
- Honarary Clan Members (10)
- Semi-pet cats (42)
- Under the iron-fist (189)
- Vids (84)
- World (516)
- Ztuff (20)
- Area1: Schwinger Central July 7, 2010The Snippety Happy bunch are back. They arrived shortly after 10pm this evening. All looked good, though wide-eyed from the trauma of their abduction and mojo-robbery. Before their homecoming btmao and I went around the area, hoping to encounter the absentee … Continue reading →calsifer
- Area1: Snippety Happy July 5, 2010We thought we had a new kitty in the hood… what do we know. The kitty we confirmed about 2 weeks was an agouti female – she was sitting right outside our door, on the ninth floor, on a night when btmao … Continue reading →calsifer
- New kitty in the hood June 8, 2010On this workday morning, as btmao and I were hurrying to the busstop to catch the feeder service, what should we spy but a pretty kitty sitting by a staircase at the foot of our block. It was a little … Continue reading →calsifer
- Sophie has found her home May 31, 2010Sophie, foster mum’s homeseeker, is now home-free. Yay!Filed under: Randomcalsifer
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Vicky April 19, 2010(Must read: Cat care refs.) Vicky is a petite 7 month old female. She is very friendly and trusting. She has a perfect long tail and has dainty tabby patches on a mostly white coat. No one knows where she … Continue reading →calsifer
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Sophie April 18, 2010(Must read: Cat care refs.) Sophie is an adult silver tabby… … with accents of ginger in her striking stripey fur. She also has a perfect long tail… And the rest of her is as pretty… as anyone could wish … Continue reading →calsifer
- Pierre may lose his eye… April 16, 2010… but it won’t be the end of the world as NIC, left in pic with best pal Jurgen, a doubly blind old bear rescued from the cruel bear bile farms of China show. Both NIC and Jurgen are of … Continue reading →calsifer
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Cherrie April 15, 2010(Must read: Cat care refs.) Pretty Cherrie is a headbutter, gentle and purry beyond words. She is sweet and inquisitive, and always respond positively to attempts to interact with her, even in mid-groom. Cherrie is an adult female calico with … Continue reading →calsifer
- Foster Mum’s homeseeker: Bee Hoon April 14, 2010(Must read: Cat care refs.) Bee Hoon is a lovely trusting female cat with bags of affection to give. A black beauty for the true cat lover. She is herself a connoisseur of the humble but delightful rustic dish, Bee … Continue reading →calsifer
- Homeseeker: Josh April 13, 2010(Must read: Cat care refs.) Josh is a young ginger spotted tabby white male cat with lovely amber eyes. He is very affectionate, calm, and loving. He is not afraid of other cats but is non-aggressive. In fact will try … Continue reading →calsifer
- Area1: Schwinger Central July 7, 2010